How competent does Thrawn even need to be? When he shows up the New Republic command ship will probably just invite him aboard along with all of his troops.
Star Wars: Ahsoka
- Thread starter Johnny Utah
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
- Joined
- Oct 14, 2016
- Messages
- 5,001
- Reaction score
- 4,869
Impressive joke. Most impressive.
Not a bad bit of referencing, huh? Y'know sometimes I amaze even myself.
- Joined
- Oct 14, 2016
- Messages
- 5,001
- Reaction score
- 4,869
I could do this all day.
No wait.
Sorry.
Edit 1:
Totally separate but I just noticed the first painting that McQuarrie did of R2 looks familiar ….
Edit 2:
Is
The joke might not look like much, but it’s got it where it counts
any better lol?
Last edited:
I finally watched the first episode.
Tat scene where Ahsoka got the map was like watching someone paint a wall in real time. I can't believe how long that scene took.
The Original Friday the 13th film has a scene where the main lead makes a pot of coffee, and it literally films her through the whole process.
Thats what the Ahsoka scene reminded me of. Just dragging out the run time.
Otherwise, it was OK. Other than the rock tune on the bike I really liked the background score. Reminded me of Williams PT score. Not great but better than what most do.
Tat scene where Ahsoka got the map was like watching someone paint a wall in real time. I can't believe how long that scene took.
The Original Friday the 13th film has a scene where the main lead makes a pot of coffee, and it literally films her through the whole process.
Thats what the Ahsoka scene reminded me of. Just dragging out the run time.
Otherwise, it was OK. Other than the rock tune on the bike I really liked the background score. Reminded me of Williams PT score. Not great but better than what most do.
- Joined
- Oct 14, 2016
- Messages
- 5,001
- Reaction score
- 4,869
Kevin Kiner has been doing great SW music for most of the animated shows since CW
Sixth Scale Man
Super Freak
ebor
Super Freak
But your missing ‘broom boy’ too…
Still works I think since none of them are real Jedis. Ahsoka comes closest but she quit.
"When gone am I, last of the lightsaber wielding Force users that actually calls himself a Jedi will you be."
RavenAsh
Morgan, congratulations! You almost got them.
I also think it's really possible Cal bites it in the third 'Jedi' game. Hell, I think he probably should.Still works I think since none of them are real Jedis. Ahsoka comes closest but she quit.
I still feel Ahsoka should have died in that fight with Vader in Rebels from a narrative standpoint. It's so thematically resonant AND a lot of these points about Luke not being the last of the Jedi during the OT would have been null and void. Not killing her there is Dave just holding onto her too long imo. As a writer, I definitely understand it, it's his baby. But that's just objectively where her end should have come.
'sound as cool, that doesn't'
Because of this forum I read that as ''Shoot first Temple of Doom, then shout 'for the Empire'..........for force sake Temple of Doom ''
chrisstbh
Thrawnald McDonald
I mean he did write around it by making her leave the Jedi order behind and no longer identify with it.
Ezra is gone. And Cal also decides to leave the order behind - we also don’t know what happens to him yet.
And Grogu is a literal baby.
But regardless, nothing changes the fact that Luke was the only one that was capable of doing what needed to be done.
jye4ever
Broke and happy
Ahsoka is not a Jedi about as much as Brian Singer hates pool parties with twinks.
Mondragon
Super Freak
- Joined
- Sep 7, 2014
- Messages
- 2,667
- Reaction score
- 3,642
.
The more Filoni "creates", the caveats just keep getting more absurd.
They can retcon in all the "*supposedly surviving Jedi" and poop them back into "reality", with space whales, time portals, calling them something else, dark, grey, medium, mild, Jedi on-a-break, whatever t-F they want, yet anything that contradicts, or $#!ts on this fact, Is implicitly alternate canon.
*(Cue; the usual except Leia contradicts it. No, she was not a Jedi yet, the whole point of the scene and next line is "pass on what you have learned", (it's why they hinged the future on Luke). There were no other Jedi left.
And what he'd learned is through free will "choice" you could recognize and thus own your worst fears, without denying them or letting them dominate or control you, and be a Jedi (without needing to possess them) still be connected to those you loved.
That was the unique instinct and transformative power Luke brought to the ROTJ.
All betrayed and denied by Disney, It wasn't enough to just tell new stories, Disney (who never liked the idea of Luke to begin with) has completely $#!& on, ruined, and made him an absolute character failure, so they can fill that void with whatever derivative crap they now come up with.
Extended: "When gone am I the last of the ightsaber wielding Force user ...that wasn't on a break, sucked through a time portal, or riding space whales to another galaxy, ...that actually calls ...or identifies ... themself as a Jedi will you be."
The more Filoni "creates", the caveats just keep getting more absurd.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Apr 19, 2013
- Messages
- 10,667
- Reaction score
- 4,311
At the heart of the OT, beneath all the goofy popcorn fare and overwrought dialogue, there resides a sense of loss and times past. Of irrevocable change that imitates real life. Maybe that's why it managed to resonate with audiences so strongly, for so long.
Filoni's problem is that he doesn't want to let go. Which is a fandom problem as well, and standard operating procedure for corporations of course. Nobody wants to leave the party.
So we get loopholes, flat mimicry and repetition stacked on top of one another in the guise of "lore", and everyone ... the characters and the fans ... overstay their welcome.
But the best parties end, just like life itself.
Of course there are stories that can still be told in a setting so vast, but they need to accept limitations. Uneven or not, Mandalorian S1 and S2 managed this a lot of the time before failure, Rogue One and Andor S1 have both accomplished effective narratives; and Solo at least managed to do no harm whether you accepted it or not.
Filoni makes millions of dollars helming a legacy property and has swarms of fans eating out of his hand and I'm just some nerd on the Internet, so hey, what do I know?
chrisstbh
Thrawnald McDonald
You're the only ones over complicating it though. She wasn't a Jedi, so there were no other Jedi. It's very simple.
Wielding the force doesn't automically make you a Jedi or a Sith. They are religions.
Similar threads
