I think it's only that polarized with the diehard comic fans. I certainly didn't
hate it, but found it surprisingly dull for a movie loaded with superheroes/villains.
The production design didn't impress me and I thought the score was pretty cheesy.
Fishburne, Irons, and other supporting cast were solid.
Affleck showed he's got the chops to play Batwayne, even if his characterization was pretty shallow.
The script was a choppy mess, but given all the ground WB needed to cover I can't see how fitting so much plot into a single movie could've borne much different results.
I suspect a lot of the audience felt "Cool ... what's next?"
Which is more of a "meh" reaction than a passionate love or hate.
I would've tweaked a scene in the ending, though:
When Martha Kent gives Lois the envelope with the wedding ring, I would keep the exact same dialog but instead have had Lois open a box and pull out a package that reads "MAGNUM TITANIUM CONDOMS XXL" along with a high-tech jar labelled "KRYPTO-LUBE."
Her eyes get huge and she bursts into tears, beating her fists on Ma Kent's wallpaper . . . .
__