I didn't mean to be, I was just saying this could just as easily go wrong. If it's great I'll be perfectly fine with it - it's not as if I'm not a fan of the characters. But let's be realistic - Snyder's vision wasn't exactly universally praised in MoS or BvS, so it's a big ask to expect everyone to change their minds now.
Well, as it should be obvious from my user name, I was a fan of JW's work long before he did Avengers. And my interpretation of his departure from the MCU after Age Of Ultron was due to burnout & frustration over Feige and others looking over his shoulder. And AoU being terrible is your opinion; I think it holds up quite well as both a stand alone film and as a setup for the others that followed. I'll be the first one to admit that his agreeing to take over JL and basically rewrite/reshoot 80% of the movie in only a few months was a colossal mistake on his part, but I'm not entirely convinced he knew at the start the extent of the changes he'd be asked to make. And no doubt WB/DC threw a *****load of cash at him to do it, so that may have been a big factor, as IIRC he was coming off his messy divorce. Regardless, I'm not sure his JL misstep is sufficient justification for viewing him as the directorial equivalent of Judas.
As far as BvS UE, I'll agree it's better than the theatrical release, but IMO it's still far from a "great" movie. And didn't Whedon back out of Batgirl because he basically admitted he couldn't come up with a good story? Sounds like writer's block to me. I don't recall any story indicating he was actually fired.
