Latest casting buzz... Holmes out, McAdams in... this hasn't officially been announced by the Studio, should hear soon...
I was one of those who felt Holmes performance was underwhelming in BB, she simply didn't have the chops to keep up with the amazing cast. I also know WB Execs felt the same way and vowed not to use in her the sequel as early as when they viewed the dailies for BB... Tommy boy didn't help matters either when he hijacked the Premiere with his antics, WB was pissed...
https://www.popoholic.com/2007/01/29/katie-holmes-out-rachel-mcadams-in/