rjszar
Super Freak
That's a great observation. Thanks for pointing that out. It doesn't matter to me which one I have, but like I said, if given the opportunity, I'd probably buy both.
Asmus Toys : Gandalf the Grey
- Thread starter Asmus
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
Clever girl.
I believe you are correct.
As I will always pose my Grey Gandalf with the hat and with messy hair, the actual hairline on the scalp means little to me. I think this withered wizard will represent the Grey very well.
I would however like to update my Gandalf the White with a better headsculpt now. And I hope that a new headsculpt based on that original Grey sculpt makes itself available in some way. Maybe a reduced price for people who purchased the original White... or a discount toward a future purchase.
rjszar
Super Freak
"This figure looks like really good cosplay, but not Ian Mckellen (if that's how you spell his name). This is less Gandalf and more the guy who sat in front of me getting high at a Phish"
"im not liking it, doesnt look like ian mckellen"
"Looks like balding, zombie Gandalf."
"Even without the wrinkles and looking too old, I just can't see any likeness similarities in the new sculpt."
Yes, most people are being fair, but in a quick read of two pages, that's what I got.
cmiller99
Super Freak
Yeah... 'most' and 'nearly'. 
The last few pages have been more negative than the preceding ten.
The last few pages have been more negative than the preceding ten.
Lejuan
Super Freak
It's not like a Hot Toys thread. People should remember that Asmus is good enough to maintain a presence here and keep their critiques respectful. Comments about cosplay and the like are a bit otp.
cmiller99
Super Freak
Yep. We're blessed that Asmus take an active interest in this board unlike virtually every other company, and we don't want to drive them away.
rjszar
Super Freak
To all the wonderful people at Asmus,
Thank you for your tireless efforts to bring us the best figures possible. Thank you for the instances when you have gone above and beyond to correct previous issues with quality at no expense to us. Thank you for participating on this forum and listening to fan input.
It will always be the case that you cannot please all of the people all of the time. Pretty much majority rules. There are cases when preferences are evenly split. Some people like rooted hair, some sculpted. Some like a character to look like they did in one movie, some another. Some even think a particular facial expression more adequately represents a certain character. When there is an ability to meet multiple preferences, as in this case, it would be nice to see that route taken. An alternate Gandalf sculpt has already been developed. Why not offer it to those who desire something different? Kaustic Plastik met fans requests for an alternate headsculpt for their upcoming William Wallace figure, and they had to start from scratch. Would you please consider offering the original Gandalf sculpt as an optional add on? Even if you plan on using this as the replacement Gandalf the White head, you could always offer two paint options, one with white hair, one with grey.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your tireless efforts to bring us the best figures possible. Thank you for the instances when you have gone above and beyond to correct previous issues with quality at no expense to us. Thank you for participating on this forum and listening to fan input.
It will always be the case that you cannot please all of the people all of the time. Pretty much majority rules. There are cases when preferences are evenly split. Some people like rooted hair, some sculpted. Some like a character to look like they did in one movie, some another. Some even think a particular facial expression more adequately represents a certain character. When there is an ability to meet multiple preferences, as in this case, it would be nice to see that route taken. An alternate Gandalf sculpt has already been developed. Why not offer it to those who desire something different? Kaustic Plastik met fans requests for an alternate headsculpt for their upcoming William Wallace figure, and they had to start from scratch. Would you please consider offering the original Gandalf sculpt as an optional add on? Even if you plan on using this as the replacement Gandalf the White head, you could always offer two paint options, one with white hair, one with grey.
Thank you for your time.
Pretty sure it was the show where they had the cart.
Stark Resilient
Super Freak
- Joined
- May 20, 2014
- Messages
- 313
- Reaction score
- 3
I hope there's an update on the new Gandalf the White head sculpt soon. I really would like to update him soon.
- Joined
- Oct 1, 2014
- Messages
- 6,114
- Reaction score
- 1,184
Look, I'm in. It looks good and I'm pleased with it so far. I wouldn't have preordered if I didn't think so. That being said, I would happily buy the sculpted head too, especially if it was part of an incentive program, like show your COA and get a discount. Asmus is good to us, and I think with Saruman and Aragorn they've proved they make a top tier product.
bunnyfreakz
Super Freak
- Joined
- Sep 28, 2014
- Messages
- 1,568
- Reaction score
- 11
I agree , the original sculpt on the left looked a lot better, but the new one isn't so bad. No idea why they decided to change him this point in the game. The eyes, the shape of the foreahead, and the eyebrowns look much better on the version on the left.
I agree old headsculpt just perfection. New one is amazing as well but old one just have better likeliness of Sir Ian Mckellen. And I think Asmus screwed again hairline just like Aragorn. Asmus if you read this, hair is part of likeliness, a little shape change can affect likeliness so much
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2014
- Messages
- 1,240
- Reaction score
- 1,444
cmiller99
Super Freak
Yeah, from the eyes up it could be any old man. The lack of widow's peak and bushy eyebrows are problematic.
zombini
Super Freak
- Joined
- Aug 24, 2014
- Messages
- 428
- Reaction score
- 4
I think the paint app will help soften the wrinkles of this 'older' looking GTG. But the question is, Is it too late? I mean May is just 2 months ahead. I am ok with this version of the headsculpt and paint but would certainly wait a few more months so that it could be improved to its full potential.
I am just glad ASMUS is doing this line otherwise I don't want to be forced to go to the customs route in figure collecting.
I am just glad ASMUS is doing this line otherwise I don't want to be forced to go to the customs route in figure collecting.
ghilbertit
Super Freak
- Joined
- Aug 2, 2011
- Messages
- 289
- Reaction score
- 71
Cool, can't wait to have it... are you planning on release even the original gandalf the grey sculpt you showed us in the beginning? I think that you can sell it as accessory pack to please fans of sculpted air...
Inviato dal mio SM-T535 utilizzando Tapatalk
SithThundercracker
Super Freak
The first sculpt was better (even if unpainted sculpts always seem better because you fill the details with your mind) in almost every way. It's not rooted hair fault, though: shape of the nose, cheeks, brow, eyebags (in particular)...everything looked spot on on the original proto. 
Similar threads
