Phoenixblazes
Super Freak
Constructive feedback for Inart Superman (A lot of this is gathered from discussion around the community).
Let me preface this by saying that I'm really passionate about this film, character depiction, and suit adaptation. On the outset, I think that this is a beautiful figure. It's easily the best on the market, and it rivals most customs that I've seen, if not all of them.
I've been looking forward to this, ever since the company stepped on the scene and I started to imagine what an Inart Superman could be. But if I'm being honest, I can't help but feel that they haven't put their best effort into this. And if there's a chance that improvements can be made, then why not ask for it? It's something I would be really eager to see.
Moreover, I'm aware that 1/6 has its limitations. I'm not expecting perfection. But I think the aim is to strive for perfection and deliver the best product that they possibly can. And I'm confident in this companies ability to address some of these concerns. Fortunately there's time for them to consider and implement feedback.
Let's get into it.
First and foremost, the fabric is dull. The suit is missing its characteristic sheen, which also enhances the muscle toning on the overall figure.
View attachment 665203
That's the biggest thing that jumps out at me, and I would be pleased if this point alone is addressed for the final figure. And although I can see an attempt to recreate that, I don't think that they've succeeded or captured it all that well as others have.
Hot Toys base figure, customized beautifully by Rory Kurtz.
View attachment 665196
The bicep joint is visible through the fabric, and it's extremely unsightly.View attachment 665200
The neck opening should have a narrower, more rounded appearance. This is due to a subtle curve in the front collar, and the cape wrapping more closely around the back of his neck.
View attachment 665204
View attachment 665201
The color (although it resembles the suit in real life) I believe should be adjusted to match more closely with how it appears on the screen.
View attachment 665198
When we look at Henry Cavill's Superman, we're seeing him within the confines of the film. We're not seeing him inside a backlot. These things are purposely brightened behind the scenes, to factor in color grading and lighting. Sreen tests are made, all in service of achieving the right look for the final frame. I believe the film should guide them and take priority over the real world prop.
As a good frame of reference, the black suit in Justice League was actually blue. The color hues were precisely selected with the intention to change them in post, in the event that Snyder could get his way (Which he did yay!)
Some other things which have been pointed out:
Tubing should terminate at his armpits.
View attachment 665202
Kryptonian script placement on the shoulders is too low.
View attachment 665205
Also, pattern texture is too spread apart. Cape sits too high on his shoulders (Refer again to Rory's custom).
Head to body ratio & body proportions need revision.
View attachment 665199
The likeness needs a little tuning. Portrait appears more stylized than it should be.
View attachment 665207
I would have liked to see a less gleaming expression, given that he's conflicted through most of the film. But that's just a personal preference.
All in all, it's a fairly straight forward design, so every minute detail counts.
It's a good looking piece, but it's not on par with their other work so far. Not even close to their best. It doesn't have the wow! factor that Aragorn does.
View attachment 665206View attachment 665197
I also think they're making it easy for a company like JND to do better if they tried. I passed on all BvS, JL, and ZSJL Superman figures from Hot Toys, but I think this is more on the level of what Hot Toys can do if they actually gave a ****. (And perhaps they'll try again after this).
Inart is asking a premium price that I don't feel is warranted compared to their other offerings, for something that leaves a fair amount to be desired.
Let's hope they don't get complacent. It doesn't get more iconic than Superman. He should be a prime showcase for their brand and their craft.
Message them on social media. If we can get some of these points across, then they will surely listen.
You mention JND, but imo their Cavill 1/3 scale Superman was possibly one of their most disappointing if not their worst piece.
Last edited: