Battle of the Movies - 1/4 Final!! (CLOSED)

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Re: Battle of the Movies - 1/4 Final!!

I shouldn't be participating really, haven't seen Seven Samurai.

Alien.

Definitely see Samurai when you can. It isn't just a "classic" to view so that you can say you viewed it, it's actually a genuinely great period adventure film that has a high rewatch value not too far off from something like Fellowship of the Ring.
 
Re: Battle of the Movies - 1/4 Final!!

Definitely see Samurai when you can. It isn't just a "classic" to view so that you can say you viewed it, it's actually a genuinely great period adventure film that has a high rewatch value not too far off from something like Fellowship of the Ring.
For sure. Kurosawa is an expert in cinematography and a master in moving the camera to evoke emotions. He knows how to tell a story.
 
Re: Battle of the Movies - 1/4 Final!!

Seven Samurai is one of the greatest movie, ever. Always in my top ten, and very near the top. Kurosawa was a God! there's everything in that movie. Love, emotion, adventure, a criticism of society. It really shows that nothing is ever black or white but rather a deep grey.

And as Khev says, it's not just a classic. Classics often feel good but sometimes old too. This movie never feels its age.
 
Re: Battle of the Movies - 1/4 Final!!

This is apples and brussles sprouts comparison. They're both excellent in their own regard but as much as I like and respect Seven Samurai, I have to go with Alien. It is an unfair paring if you ask me, might as well pit Alien vs. Citizen Kane (which BTW, Kane SHOULD be in the top 8 imho....) And considering ESB won over GFII (I think genre bias helped that one, and Raiders), so genre bias help Alien! :D

Curious as to why this wasn't pitted against Godfather I, as the every other title from the first post seemed to be the way of the matchups.
 
Re: Battle of the Movies - 1/4 Final!!

After seeing thoroughbred's TGTB&TU and The Godfather Part 2 losing to nostalgia nags Raiders & Empire, I'm going to switch voting strategy and jinx Alien this time.
 
Re: Battle of the Movies - 1/4 Final!!

My voting has been kind of arbitrary from match to match. This one was decided on what I'd watch again right now.

Seven Samurai
 
Re: Battle of the Movies - 1/4 Final!!

Seven Samurai

Like in sports its all about the match-ups.

I would have picked ALIEN over ESB.
 
Re: Battle of the Movies - 1/4 Final!!

Live scores:
- 24 hrs more for voting..


8 - Seven Samurai
7 - Alien
 
Re: Battle of the Movies - 1/4 Final!!

Alien 8:8 Seven Samurai

NEXT VOTE WINS. Voting is not permitted to those who have voted before in this duel.
 
Re: Battle of the Movies - 1/4 Final!!

i Will fight anyone in thunderdome for the honors!!!!
 
Re: Battle of the Movies - 1/4 Final!!

Goddamn it... First I take a test that makes me choose what would disappear from the earth; burgers or tacos, now THIS? This has been a painful day.

Alien is one of my favorite sci-fi movies, and my favorite sci-fi horror specifically, and Seven Samurai, man, it's such a masterpiece of simplicity.... I vote.... Sigh:

S E V E N S A M U R A I S E V E N S A M U R A I S E V E N S A M U R A I

What a soul crushing task, I never thought I'd vote against Sci-Fi, had this been 2001 it would've been different. Curse whoever burdened me with this blasted responsibility.
 
Re: Battle of the Movies - 1/4 Final!!

Alien 8:9 Seven Samurai
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


1 // 4 F I N A L::
Match -4:


THE GODFATHER /1972/
the-godfather.jpg



.vs.


SCARFACE /1983/
ef7825efac151c25a1f799b8d5e634fa7f083aa2.jpg
 
Back
Top