Sideshow 1/6 R2-D2

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Too bad I missed out on this Disney deal. I'd actually consider getting another if I could get it at this price. I'd go the opposite route with the figure than I did this time and give him a clean look as opposed to the dirty weathering I did. Hope Disney gets him back in stock again and they do the same deal.

I'm guessing it will come back in stock. R2 is now a Disney character... I can't imagine it's in stock a week or so and then that's it.

Thank s dave in fact it s my tusken display



Love the display!
 
The paint looks normal - you asked before and got the same reply.



Did you mention to them the few specific issues? The dents and the chipped/rough spots around the ring? Because if you just sent them the images, I'm not surprise they didn't know what you were talking about, they go through a ton of emails a day I'm sure.

Yup. They are standing by their decision. They say mine looks no different than theirs or the one in the gallery. Not too impressed in my first Sideshow piece in many years.

Tap'd from my LG G3
 
Yup. They are standing by their decision. They say mine looks no different than theirs or the one in the gallery. Not too impressed in my first Sideshow piece in many years.

Tap'd from my LG G3

Damn, that really sucks. My R2 came with a couple little dents and blemishes, but your dome clearly appears to be much more dented and flawed than any others I've seen.
 
Han's jacket was white and gold.
xPenny yellow parka.jpg
 
Garemlin, I went back and looked at your pics. I think you're being really fickle here. Every single R2 has those marks, seams, and indents. Mine too. You won't be getting a better one as they were all produced this way. I'm not sure how you'd pick out those minor negatives after all the positives of this guy.
 

Take out the electronics and lights, then take all your remaining frustration of SSC's qc and smash it beyond all recognition. That's how i would approach it :r2d2line:computer
Haha thanks fellas. I'll go grab the hammer then. The last replacement I got was for a body so it didn't take much to snap into a few pieces.
 
Garemlin, I went back and looked at your pics. I think you're being really fickle here. Every single R2 has those marks, seams, and indents. Mine too. You won't be getting a better one as they were all produced this way. I'm not sure how you'd pick out those minor negatives after all the positives of this guy.

Some say it isn't bad. Some say it is horrible. I don't know what to think. My biggest issues are these:

The chunks of silver pain in several of the seams

a8dcf282a6972eec5c556404fc814302.jpg


fd7f9e79bc171183f15ceaf3e22efda1.jpg



This looks like a blob of paint. And it is not even the same shade of blue

8ebc459a7e89325d68d15c49d3f29dc6.jpg




Is that being fickle??? I think it looks pretty jacked up myself.
 
RED: This is a manufacturing defect. Not normal. Significant.
YELLOW: This is a manufacturing defect. Minor.
GREEN: This looks like part of the design/weathering paint application.

r2-1.jpg
r2-2.jpg
r2-3.jpg

Get them to do a dome swap or return the whole figure for a full refund. Other members have had domes with fewer and less severe issues replaced. I can't imagine the entire figure costs them more than $20-30 to manufacture (I'm being very generous here, not including development and tooling), so replacing it shouldn't be the issue they're making it out to be.
 
RED: This is a manufacturing defect. Not normal. Significant.
YELLOW: This is a manufacturing defect. Minor.
GREEN: This looks like part of the design/weathering paint application.

View attachment 172704
View attachment 172705
View attachment 172706

Get them to do a dome swap or return the whole figure for a full refund. Other members have had domes with fewer and less severe issues replaced. I can't imagine the entire figure costs them more than $20-30 to manufacture (I'm being very generous here, not including development and tooling), so replacing it shouldn't be the issue they're making it out to be.


Thanks for pointing all of these out. And as much as I thought. I would be happy with a dome swap. But they are standing by their opinion that mine looks exactly like theirs. My only option is to pay shipping to return it for a refund. They will not even do a full exchange. Total BS if you ask me.

And on the top pic the bottom red circled I assumed that was part of the weathering/damage look.
 
Looks the same as Momaw's to me, and SS offered a replacement on that dome. Resend the pics with Pixel's kindly applied marks and perhaps they'll be more persuaded by your claim. I don't think you're being 'fickle'.
 
And on the top pic the bottom red circled I assumed that was part of the weathering/damage look.

Send them the images I circled.

How did you pay for this? Credit Card? PayPal? Call the payment processor and complain the vendor is giving you a hard time with a warranty concern if they won't budge after seeing the circled images.
 
And on the top pic the bottom red circled I assumed that was part of the weathering/damage look.

Regarding both the left and right circled areas, I have the exact same marks on my R2. So I expect any one you get might have those too. You're then left with the middle marks, is it worth a new some just for that slightly sloppy paint app? I think the worst imperfection by far is that dark blue blob in the third picture.
Also the Silver and blue rings are not part of the dome so you would possibly need a whole new R2.
 
The dents from the other (previous) images are also very noticeable defects that I haven't seen in everyone else's photos.

Those gouges are also serious defects and evidence of haphazard quality control of the injection moulding process. They should not be present on any finished product at any price point, let alone a high end collectible.

Fragility and plastic thinness due to scale are one thing, but injection moulding issues are something else entirely. Many of the parts seen in the photos posted so far should have been scrapped after inspection, prior to paint application, if they could not be repaired in production.

I don't let crap like that slide on IR receivers I have manufactured and sell for $20 retail.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top