Don't need a magnifying glass to see the broken plant , but honestly the missed paint spot on the vine and by her thigh didn't bother me but the spot on the base is pretty big. If the base was fine I'd be happy with a plant replacement
To me, those are all easy fixes. Ask for a new plant, you'll get it. Even if you don't, easily fixed. And the base and vine paint is easy enough to do yourself. A credit is what I'd ask for.