It surprises me that many of you prefer the 12" version. Regardless of price, I still think that 12" Luke seems like he has chapped lips, and the hair looks crusty and more cheaply sculpted. I also prefer the eyes on the larger version. Sincerely, I am not "having a hard time" admitting the 12" looks better because I paid more for the bigger one, I honestly do think that the PF looks superior. I want the one that looks best, regardless of price. My gut response would be that the 12" fans are having a hard time admitting that the PF Luke looks better, to justify their spending less money. I realize that neither statement is true, though. We each see them through our own preferences and I'm glad that we have both lines, so that those of us with different tastes and opinions can find the one that we like the best. Nobody will convince me that the smaller looks better, and vice versa. Hopefully we can disagree politely and go about collecting our preferred line, seeing the good in both sizes.