River Tam statue by Phil Robinson
- Thread starter theguru1
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
uscmhicks
Super Freak
Summer is at Wales Comic con (I think in April). Maybe if this arrives in time you could get her to sign it lol!. Hope those updates come sooner rather than later.
Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
Well, I'm not actually in the UK, so a little hard for me to do that myself. Not that it would matter, based on progress so far, there is no way it would be done in the next 3 months anyway.
Funny enough, Summer was at my local comic con a few years ago, but of course, no statue.
Funny enough, Summer was at my local comic con a few years ago, but of course, no statue.
Back in January, Phil (www.facebook.com/philip.robinson.9231) said:
Needless to say, February has come and gone and there's nothing new to show. Lets see what happens next.
Needless to say, February has come and gone and there's nothing new to show. Lets see what happens next.
We are now only 1 month away from 9 years since the deposit was paid and still nothing new. So I sent a message:
"This isn't going to be like last year is it, months and months and months of asking to see any update/photos, to only get a couple of disappointing pics in very late December."
Phil's reply..... "No need to be rude"
I guess after almost 9 years, he finds the truth to be rude.
"This isn't going to be like last year is it, months and months and months of asking to see any update/photos, to only get a couple of disappointing pics in very late December."
Phil's reply..... "No need to be rude"
I guess after almost 9 years, he finds the truth to be rude.
Sidewinder
Super Freak
Jesus Christ! We're in the middle of a lockdown! This guy should be holed up in his house finishing this statue. What else has he got to do? How can a statue take 9 years to complete? Absolute insanity. I hope this guy doesn't get another commission again.
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
I suspect he will, since while I've made a thread on a couple of forums, most of what he does is on Facebook, including a specific page for sculpture (https://www.facebook.com/pages/cate...nt/Philip-Robinson-Sculpture-326458861044538/). Where he seems to have a few fans, tho how many have actually tried to deal with him from a business point of view is hard to know.
As for what else he Phil has to do, looking at that page, Yoda is now at Version 6, while River is maybe V0.7
For anyone who has been following along I'm sure this won't come as any surprise, but I've yet to hear any word from Phil over the past month, even tho the statue is meant be be completed within 2 weeks time.
So I've sent him a reminder, along with pointing out the fact that it is now officially 9 years since I paid the deposit.
So I've sent him a reminder, along with pointing out the fact that it is now officially 9 years since I paid the deposit.
dao2
Super Freak
9 years and it doesn't even look very good :|
uscmhicks
Super Freak
Here is what I assume will be the final statue.
For anyone that needs a reminder, this is the reference image that we were going for.
Let me know what you all think, honest feedback is welcome.
For anyone that needs a reminder, this is the reference image that we were going for.
Let me know what you all think, honest feedback is welcome.
Last edited:
j97e1
Super Freak
I can recognize what it supposed to be because I'm a fan of the movie and familiar with the scene. Otherwise I'd think it's some random girl with a caveman forehead and brow. Frankenstein's monster's sister or something...
uscmhicks
Super Freak
Like I said a few posts up, nine years ago it would have looked better but even then still custom and flawed. The body sculpt looks good to me and the tailoring is decent.
The thing that stands out the most I'd say is the headsculpt and hair are lacking and possibly the paint. I also notice that the hand pointing upward doesn't look to be gripping the weapon very well. The sculpt looks like a custom 1/6 figure and that just isn't good enough at this scale imo. This is 1/4 scale right?
If I was a big enough fan I would probably send this on to a reputable, trusted artist who could alter those issues and maybe completely redo the head, hands and paint. It could vastly improve the piece.
You certainly shouldn't have to send it to anyone though and you'll have probably lost most of your enjoyment of this piece given what's happened.
Regardless, I hope you receive it soon and get something out of it man.
Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
The thing that stands out the most I'd say is the headsculpt and hair are lacking and possibly the paint. I also notice that the hand pointing upward doesn't look to be gripping the weapon very well. The sculpt looks like a custom 1/6 figure and that just isn't good enough at this scale imo. This is 1/4 scale right?
If I was a big enough fan I would probably send this on to a reputable, trusted artist who could alter those issues and maybe completely redo the head, hands and paint. It could vastly improve the piece.
You certainly shouldn't have to send it to anyone though and you'll have probably lost most of your enjoyment of this piece given what's happened.
Regardless, I hope you receive it soon and get something out of it man.
Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
Yes it is 1/4 scale or at least it should be.
I've spoken with Phil and he's agreed to a number of fixes.
- The weapons will be re-sculpted and re-painted, the sword is too short and the axe isn't exactly right and I find the paint apps, especially on the axe just doesn't say razor sharp. I too pointed out the thumb holding the axe, or not holding it, making it look like the weapon would just fall out. Not sure if that will be fixed.
- The hair will be redone using black, since it more or less is, especially in the reference photo, with the eyes looking up/forward rather the down like they are now.
- My biggest issue was with the dress. The cloth is just too heavy and the overall fit across the chest and down the side just makes it all look too big and bulky. This is the first time I've seen the dress, so Phil is going to redo it, I hope with a lighter, bit more transparent type fabric, something like silk.
I've spoken with Phil and he's agreed to a number of fixes.
- The weapons will be re-sculpted and re-painted, the sword is too short and the axe isn't exactly right and I find the paint apps, especially on the axe just doesn't say razor sharp. I too pointed out the thumb holding the axe, or not holding it, making it look like the weapon would just fall out. Not sure if that will be fixed.
- The hair will be redone using black, since it more or less is, especially in the reference photo, with the eyes looking up/forward rather the down like they are now.
- My biggest issue was with the dress. The cloth is just too heavy and the overall fit across the chest and down the side just makes it all look too big and bulky. This is the first time I've seen the dress, so Phil is going to redo it, I hope with a lighter, bit more transparent type fabric, something like silk.
For those wondering what the current status is, I am still waiting on the agreed required changes that were going to be done by the end of June to be completed. At this stage I have no revised ETA. Will let you all know if I get any updates.
Similar threads
