R_R_X

Maybe I'm misunderstanding here. Are you saying mass reactions = good? I mean from a studio perspective I'm sure that's very true, but...

:exactly: I've read comments like this is HBO's best hour of television, that it's perhaps the best romance ever told on TV, that it's...

Bad A.I so it's not really a big deal, happens in the game too.

That scene sticks out like a sore thumb, I don't know what was more ridiculous Bill firing in the middle of the road like a sitting duck...

They're going to fish all the Emmys with this one considering the over dramatic response to this episode online and the fact HBO is...

I didn't, Bill is a completely different person in the game whom everyone had a hard time with, an extremely paranoid and antisocial...

Me too! So glad to finally see some comments about this in here. We watched it last night and all I was thinking during the piano scene...

I'm glad I wasn't the only one to feel this way.

I really liked the episode, but it was absolutely pointless. I watched it believing Bill was going to still be alive and we'd get some...

Yeah it wasn't terrible, but I do feel we missed something with not getting any Joel, Ellie, and Bill interaction. The Emmy fishing...

I agree they fell in love waaaay too fast especially with a hermit paranoid character like Bill, would've felt more organic if we saw...

Why couldn't we get this from HT for their Mando figure?

I agree with all this. Yes the love story was well done but having an entire episode dedicated to it and not even have Bill meet Ellie...